Best Fertilizer Spreader Reviews & Buyer Guide – 2021 Edition

Fertilizing your grass and garden can be the most effective way to help your lawn bloom without much effort. When using a recommended fertilizer for St. Augustine grass, Bermuda grass, or other, you can expect to see stronger and thicker grass, along with the color, without you needing to do much at all.

If you’re an experienced gardener or even a beginner, you probably know how tedious fertilizing can be. You don’t walk around your lawn with a heavy bag, inconsistently spreading all the fertilizer hand by hand. And you don’t like to use the overpriced lawn care services that come out every few months.

Thankfully, some creative souls created fertilizer spreaders that are an easy and effective way to use and spread fertilizer on your lawn that anyone can use. There are several styles of fertilizer spreaders all based on the size and area that you need to cover, which I’ll describe below.

In a rush? These are the ones we recommend. But keep reading if you want more info on each.

BEST DROP SPREADER
Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader
BEST CHEST MOUNTED
Solo, Inc. Solo 421 20-Pound Capacity Portable Chest-mount...
BEST CART SPREADER
Scotts Elite Spreader
BEST DROP SPREADER
Scotts 76565 Turf Builder Classic Drop Spreader
BEST CHEST MOUNTED
Solo, Inc. Solo 421 20-Pound Capacity Portable Chest-mount...
BEST CART SPREADER
Scotts Elite Spreader

What is the Best Type of Fertilizer Spreader?

The two main types of spreaders are: drop and broadcast. There are pros and cons for each type. While drop spreaders disperse the fertilizer more evenly, applying it will take longer as it is a slower process typically. Broadcast on the other hand will get the fertilizer spreaded at a much faster rate with perhaps not evenly unless you have a trained eye.

Spreader typeDropBroadcast
Lawn SizeUnder 5000 Sq. ftOver 5000 Sq ft to 20,000 Sq. ft
Application Coverage(Controlled) Even(Somewhat controlled) More Spray
Application SpeedSlowFaster
Hopper SizeTypically smallerSmall to Large Options Avail.

So choosing which type is best for your needs would be based on the overall size of your yard and if you want more precise control of applying the fertilizer. I typically will use my drop spreader on smaller front yards I work on. This way I know the application is even and another benefit of the drop spreader is that there is no excess products laying all over the driveway and sidewalks. Plus wind isn’t a consideration since drop spreaders do exactly that, drop the product where you want it.

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B002ZTK09U&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B002ZTK09U

The Scotts Turf Builder Drop Spreader is my go-to for smaller yards. Adding fertilizer is easy and the hopper is big enough usually for one or two fills. If you have a yard under 5000 sq ft then I’m sure you’ll like this one. Check it out on Amazon here

For more commercial applications I like my Argi-Fab Tow Behind Drop Spreader. Holds up to 175-lbs of product (around 17 gallons) and works great being towed by my John Deer. The universial mount will work on any tractor you have. Great for dropping product on larger yards, like 1 acre and higher.

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B000KL1L6Q&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B000KL1L6Q

Check it out on Amazon here.

Broadcast Spreader Options

Okay, now there are a few ways you can disperse the fertilizer with a broadcast, and because of this, people have found innovative ways to do this. Most commonly, there are three broadcast spreader options. These are:

  • Chest-mounted
  • Cart-style
  • Handheld

Chest-Mounted Fertilizer Spreaders

In short, a chest-mounted fertilizer spreader is a fertilizer spreader that attaches to your chest. Usually, chest-mounted systems have small adjustable straps to make the unit more comfortable and can be altered should it be too heavy or tight. 

SOLO 421 Chest-Mounted Fertilizer Spreader Review – My Recommended

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B000BWZD0O&Format= SL160 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li2&o=1&a=B000BWZD0O

The Solo 421 chest-mounted fertilizer spreader is one of the best, all-rounded fertilizer spreader. As you can tell from the title, the Solo 421 is a chest-mounted fertilizer spreader that attaches easily to anyone with the adjustable straps.

Something else to note is the number of fertilizer pellets you can carry at any one time. The Solo 421 has a 20-lbs plastic container with a screw-lid on the top that you can store your pellets in. The screw-lid is something we don’t see all the time in fertilizer spreaders and can not only help with the distribution but can also protect you as the operator to prevent the pellets from jumping up and hitting you.

The Solo 421 has a very efficient yet effective distribution method that requires you as the operator to wind a crank to distribute the pellets while walking around the zone you wish to fertilize. The crank has a small plastic handle and doesn’t get in the way of anything else on the system or your chest. 

Once cranked, a small distribution spinner will pull down pellets and spread them in front of you accordingly. There are also side-barriers that protect your hand from the pellets’ speed, which, again, is a very neat feature we don’t see all the time. 

The only downside that we get from the Solo 421 is that the system doesn’t have any warranty. However, as the mechanics are all high-quality, and Solo being a reputable brand in the garden industry, we feel there is little chance of your system breaking once it’s working. 

Overall, the Solo 421 is one of the best chest-mounted and overall fertilizer spreaders on the market from its reasonable price point and many features. The only downside is that this is not for big gardens, but for every day, small gardens that you may have at home. We would recommend this for any beginner, or if you’ve got a small-medium sized garden.

Cart-Style Spreaders

Another option you may want to consider is the cart-style spreaders. As the name suggests, a cart-style spreader is one that you can push around. Usually, you fill up a tank with your fertilizer and move the spreader around, where even and accurate dispersion will occur per wheel turn. These are the most common spreaders for more extensive or longer lawns.

Scotts Elite Spreader Review – My Recommended

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B077JBGG4H&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B077JBGG4H

Best cart-style, large-coverage spreader.

Another great spreader from a great brand, the Scotts Elite spreader, is an innovative spreader that’s been designed for the bigger gardens or even farms in mind. Realistically, the Scotts Elite spreader isn’t just for garden fertilizers. You could add anything such as lawn-seed, ice salt, and indeed fertilizer. 

The Scotts Elite spreader is built from a robust sturdy frame that is not only powder-coated for a smoother look but also to protect against hash-weathers, as it’s also improved against rusting. Something else to note is that the bin itself is made from hardened plastic to further protect against harsh environments. The full plastic tires are nice and should last the lifetime of the unit.

Something that we love with the Elite spreader is its large capacity (up to 20k square ft of product), allowing you to cover bigger gardens and even farms within a matter of minutes. The dual rotor tech that is on this spreader is quite impressive. This is the first dual-rotor spreader I have tried and am impressed with the 6 ft radius it generates and is super accurate in the release of the product. I don’t need to second guess myself if the product is being distributed evenly or not.

The Scotts Elite spreader comes fully adjusted and assembled so you can crack on with the critical spreading without needing to spend hours trying to get it to work correctly. 

All things considered, the Scotts Elite spreader is one of the best spreaders for large-use, as this is quite big, it’s unlikely to fit into a small garden and be used as effectively as you would a larger garden. 

Hand-Held Fertilizer Spreaders

The last option is a small, hand-held fertilizer spreader. These are another relatively common method for spreading fertilizer, but they are usually relatively small. Hand-held fertilizers are small systems that often turn a lever, and it will disperse the small pellets, which can be quite tiring but can be used for more accuracy when spreading. 

Scott’s Whirl Handy SpreaderMy Recommended

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07KMWVBJS&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B07KMWVBJS

The Scott’s Whirl Handy Spreader is one of the best value for money fertilizer spreaders on this list and for a good reason. Another Scott’s product in this list, the handy spreader, is a super-efficient, lightweight, and overall excellent value spreader.

If you have a compact lawn or a smaller area to fertilize, then the EverGreen handy spreader may be ideal for you. The compact size of the lawn spreader makes it perfect for fertilizing smaller lawns. The EverGreen Handy Spreader has five separate settings allowing you to control how much fertilizer is being spat out at any time.

This is a two-handed spreader, one for turning the crank to spit the fertilizer out and one to hold the system. Thankfully, Scott has thought about this and what it might mean for arm fatigue, and because of this, Scotts has integrated a wrist/arm support when holding, which is an excellent addition to your health. 

This fertilizer spreader is by far one of the cheapest on this list, and possibly on the market, but Scott’s have really thought about the quality of the product. Although a little flimsy and cheap-feeling, this fertilizer spreader is worth it if you are not wanting to spend a whole lot and wanting to increase your grass’s strength.

Overall, if you’re looking for an okay-quality, cost-effective fertilizer spreader that does the job it needs to do, then the Whirl Handy Spreader should fit right into your gardening arsenal without issue. 

Buyer Guide – What to look for in a Fertilizer Spreader

Holding Capacity

fertilizer spreader holding capacity

When you look for a fertilizer spreader, you should always consider how much your spread can hold. Obviously, this depends on how big your lawn or garden you’re trying to fertilize is, but it is a significant selling point for many. 

For small, house-sized gardens, a capacity of 5-10 lbs should be more than enough to spread over your lawn, however, if you have a slightly bigger lawn such as a farm, you may want to opt for a higher capacity such as 80-100 lbs, but these are mainly for industrial use. 

Design and Robustness

fertilizer spreader design

When looking for a fertilizer spreader, you always need to buy once, use forever. If a fertilizer spreader has a very low price tag, you may want to consider the build quality. You do not want a flimsy and weak build; otherwise, it will cause more problems than it will solve, and you may even need to rebuy.

You should also note the size. Depending on how much room you have, usually, fertilizer spreaders are better kept inside, and if you have no room for it, make sure you have stainless steel and or treated plastic if you want to keep it outside. 

Precision when Spreading

Fertilizer spreader precision

The whole reason you’re buying a fertilizer spreader is to help you spread and fix any inconsistencies when applying fertilizer by hand. Although you may want a cheap spreader, spending a little more upfront can save time and money as the spreader should hopefully spread it out evenly. 

If you don’t buy a spreader to precisely target your grass evenly, you may end up with underdeveloped grass, inconsistency, and patches. It’s essential to make sure that you consider your accuracy, consistency, and precision when looking for a fertilizer spreader. 

Value

A common decision for many of us is the value of the device. Fertilizer spreaders are usually relatively inexpensive for the time you’ll save, and the benefits of using one will bring to you and your garden.

When looking at fertilizer spreaders, you may see some very cheap options that will look ok but may have imperfections, failings, and other poor qualities that you don’t want when using a fertilizer spreader.

If you can afford it, it’s always better to spend a little more upfront on a more beneficial or premium looking fertilizer spreader to ensure that it doesn’t bring up any problems down the line. 

OTHER BEST FERTILIZER SPREADERS OF 2021

As we mentioned at the start, we’re going to be looking at the other best fertilizer spreaders on the market today, and some of their perks, and if they have any weaknesses. We’ve given each one a unique title that we feel they fit, so you can get a better gauge for what you will need for you and your garden.

Katai 2L Hand-Held Fertilizer Spreader Review – Best Value

q? encoding=UTF8&ASIN=B07F9Y24Y2&Format= SL250 &ID=AsinImage&MarketPlace=US&ServiceVersion=20070822&WS=1&tag=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en USir?t=crabgrasslawncom 20&language=en US&l=li3&o=1&a=B07F9Y24Y2

The Katai 2L hand-held fertilizer is a very small yet significant spreader that you can use in your garden. The 2-liter handheld spreader, although relatively small, is very easy to use and has a number of settings on the screw-top lid in order for you to spread the right amount of fertilizer, whether you’re using it on your lawn, driveway, or allotment. 

The design features a hardened plastic, usually in Blue, that has several gauges on the side, showing how many liters you have in at any one time. These range from 0.5, 1,1.5, and 2l. The Katai also comes with a small scoop should you only wish to use a certain amount of scoops from your fertilizer bag. 

As with most fertilizers, this one is not set to only accept a certain type of pellet. You could use the Katai for de-icer or ice salts, planting/spreading seeds, pest control, and anything else you can spread that would fit through the holes. 

Although relatively cheap, the build is straightforward and fairly robust, and we have no complaints as it does the job described on the tin.

Overall, if you’re looking for a small, handheld, and very inexpensive solution to spreading pellets (not just fertilizers), then the Katai may be ideal for you and your garden. 

Conclusion

No matter how you plan on using your fertilizer spreader, there are proven benefits to using one. Whether you’re trying to improve your lawn’s strength, or color, or even just to fix small patches in your garden, we hope that one of the systems on this list will accommodate your list.

If you’re looking for affordable or inexpensive systems, you may opt for either the Katai or Scott’s Handy Spreader that will get the job done in a more efficient and effective manner. 

If you’ve got a slightly bigger lawn or area that needs fertilizing, then you may opt for the Scott’s EverGreen Drop spreader. If you are looking for an all-around best fertilizer spreader than our first option, the Solo 421 may be the option you want to look at.

Regardless, remember to follow our buyer’s guide to ensure that you get the best quality, more efficient, and most effective fertilizer spreader to make your grass grow healthier and more colorful for years to come.

2 thoughts on “Best Fertilizer Spreader Reviews & Buyer Guide – 2021 Edition”

  1. In your review and recommendation of the Scotts Elite Lawn Spreader, you say:
    “The Elite spreader has a 22-inch spread pattern that is very consistent when dropping and even efficient as you can run with this spreader to get the best distribution rapidly.”

    First of all, the spread pattern of this spreader is much greater than 22 inches. It’s a broadcast spreader and has a spread pattern of approximately 6 feet.

    Secondly, the spreader setting allows the material being spread to fall onto the impellers at a constant rate, without regard to the speed that the spreader is traveling. Therefore, the faster the spreader travels the thinner the coverage and broader the coverage area.

    Reply
    • Thanks Gary.:) In my editing I was jumping around from different spreaders and had that in the wrong spot. I have updated it. Thanks again. If you have any feedback on what you use, would love to hear it.

      Reply

Leave a Comment