Both St. Augustine grass and Bermuda grass are great warm-season lawn grasses. You’d pick them if you live in warm areas and would like to grow a great lawn. Some people mix the two turfgrasses, others choose to seed or sod with just one. Should you choose Bermuda grass or St. Augustine grass?
In summary, Bermuda grass is highly drought-resistant and can tolerate hot weather in summer without water while St. Augustine grass will require a lot of water to do well. Another major difference is that St. Augustine is shade-resistant while Bermuda grass does not do well in shady areas.
If you just want my recommendations, then these are good choices. For Bermuda seed go with…
- Uses up to 30% less water versus ordinary grass seed
- Grass establishes quickly
- Contains grass seed varieties that thrive in both sun and shade
Affiliate links and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on: 2023-12-09
…and for St. Augustine, go with these plugs: (note there is no such thing at St. Augustine seed, use plugs instead).
Looking for the Best St. Augustine Plugs?
I recommend the Sod Solutions St. Augustine Plugs. Click on the link below to get their latest price.
For more options, check out my article on where to buy St. Augustine grass seed.
Whether you live in Texas, Florida, or areas where the climate is a bit warmer than the rest of the states, you want to consider the differences, pros, and cons of these two kinds of grass before growing them on your lawn.
Let’s delve deeper and compare these two great turfgrasses, their similarities, and differences.
St. Augustine Grass vs Bermuda Grass – Differences
Both grasses are great at choking out weeds such as dandelions, crabgrass, and even quackgrass. This is because both St. Augustine grass and Bermuda grass can grow thick and full, leaving no room for weeds to grow and compete with your turfgrass.
|St. Augustine Grass||Bermuda Grass|
|It requires at least 5 hours of direct sunlight to grow and thrive really well. However, St. Augustine grass can do better than Bermuda in low light conditions.||Bermuda grass requires full sunlight all day long to grow optimally. Less sunlight will retard its growth due to reduced photosynthesis.|
|St. Augustine requires twice as much water as Bermuda grass - ¾ inch to 1 ½ inches of water per week. This may be up-to 4 times of watering per week in summer.||Bermuda lawns require watering three times a week during summer and can go without watering in winter because of dormancy.|
|St. Augustine grass is a fertilizer-intensive grass, needing to be fertilized every two months or with a slow-release nitrogen fertilizer every 10 weeks.||It is recommended that you fertilize overseeded Bermuda grass, and do so twice - in December and February.|
|The easiest way to establish a St. Augustine lawn is using sod.||A Bermuda lawn is best established from grass seed.|
|Saint Augustine grass has a higher tolerance for shade.||Bermuda grass does not tolerate shade at all.|
|Mainly used for lawns.||Bermuda grass can be grown for hay, on golf courses, and as a lawn grass.|
|Does not do well with foot traffic stress.||Highly tolerant to foot traffic and stress.|
|St. Augustine lawns are expensive to maintain because they require frequent fertilization, mowing and watering.||A Bermuda lawn is less expensive and easier to establish a thicker turf with frequent mowing.|
St. Augustine has large flat stems and broad coarse leaves while Bermuda grass has short flat leaves. Bermuda grass is usually identified by its spikelets that are borne in four or five slender spikes at the tips of the upright stems.
Both St. Augustine and Bermuda grass have great weed tolerance to common lawn weeds such as broadleaf plantain. They grow and spread fast, forming a thick, full lawn. As such, they’re able to crowd out and kill weeds on their own so you won’t use many lawn weed killers.
If your lawn gets easily infested by weeds such as crabgrass, planting either Bermuda or St. Augustine will help you control them easily because these two will easily compete with the weeds and overcome them with ease.
St. Augustine Grass Identification (Pictures)
St. Agustine grass (Stenotaphrum secundatum) is best suited for tropical and sub-tropical climates. Coastal regions are great because of the warmth, as the grass will thrive well in heat and do poorly in cool regions.
It is often described as a dark green lawn grass with broad, flat leaves. It grows fast, crowding and choking out weeds. Like Bermuda grass, it spreads above-the-ground runners (also called stolons) and develops into a thick, dense turf rather easily.
Various St. Augustine grass cultivars have been developed, including Floratam, Palmetto, Floratine, St. Augustine decline, Captiva, Raleigh, and Texas common.
Here are pictures to help you identify St. Augustine grass:
Bermuda Grass Identification (with Pictures)
Also referred to as, Cynodon dactylon, Bermuda grass has fairly short blades that measure 2 to 15 cm. The leaves appear to be grey-green. The root system is deep while the stems are a bit flat and can grow as tall as 30 cm when erect.
Mowing often activates lateral growth, making your lawn thick and full. When nodes touch the ground, the grass will grow and spread laterally on the surface, sprouting new leaves and shoots. Stolons, rhizomes, and seeds are the main ways this grass spreads.
Here’s a photo of Bermuda grass to help you with identification:
Long Bermuda Grass
Bermuda Sod on Rolls
See also my article comparing Bermuda grass vs crabgrass
Which One to Choose
The type of grass you’ll choose for your lawn depends on your preferences and the setup of your lawn.
Is your lawn covered with shade?
I would strongly recommend planting St. Augustine grass if your yard is surrounded by trees and buildings that block sunlight for most of the day. Did you know St. Augustine is the most shade-tolerant warm-season grass?
However, if your lawn receives a full day of direct sunlight, choose Bermuda grass as it thrives better under full-light conditions.
How much traffic will there be on your lawn?
Another factor to consider is traffic. Some grass species do well under foot traffic stress while others don’t. For example, Bermuda grass is great for heavy foot traffic while St. Augustine grass does not tolerate foot traffic so well.
What’s the overall climate like?
Both Bermuda and St. Augustine are warm-season grasses and will thrive a lot better in warm conditions. You can choose either of the two or mix the seeds and sod when planting your lawn. If you do, note that Bermuda grass can easily outgrow St. Augustine grass, especially with frequent mowings.
St Augustine Grass Pros and Cons
Just like any other type of grass, there are advantages and disadvantages to St. Augustine grass. So without further ado, let’s take a look at the pros and cons of St. Augustine grass to help you decide whether it’s worth planting or not.
What Is the Advantage of St Augustine Grass?
There are plenty of advantages to St. Augustine grass that tend to outweigh its disadvantages.
What Are the Disadvantages of St. Augustine Grass?
Bermuda Grass Pros and Cons
Bermuda grass is native to tropical and sub-tropical countries worldwide and offers myriad benefits for homeowners but does come with a few flaws.
What Is the Advantage of Bermuda Grass?
What Are the Disadvantages of Bermuda Grass?
Best St Augustine Grass Seed
Many homeowners are led to believe that a St. Augustine lawn can be planted from scratch with grass seeds or to fill bare spots. But this is a big mistake, mainly because people are less knowledgeable about the differences between warm-season grasses and cool-season grasses.
While all cool-season grasses can be grown from seed, it doesn’t work the same way for warm-season grasses.
There are two reasons why warm-season grasses can’t be seeded:
- First is because these seeds are highly variable and will result in a non-uniform lawn
- Second, hybrid varieties don’t produce viable seeds
Hence warm-season grasses are usually grown via sod, sprigs, or plugs.
So the answer to the question of what is the best St. Augustine grass seed is there is none available to buy either online or at your local garden center.
Where to Buy St Augustine Grass Seed
You will probably not be able to get your hands on St. Augustine grass seeds but you can buy St. Augustine grass sod and plugs.
Is St Augustine More Expensive than Bermuda?
St. Augustine grass is a little less expensive than Bermuda grass at $0.30 to $0.80 per square foot compared to $0.35 to $0.85 per square foot. The cost of St Augustine grass also depends on where you shop and whether you’re buying grass sod or plugs.
Can I Mix Bermuda Grass with St Augustine?
Bermuda grass plays nice with St. Augustine grass. You can use this mix to quickly and affordably fix bare spots in your lawn that would take much longer with sod.
Is St Augustine a Good Lawn Grass?
St. Augustine grass is a great choice for lawns in warmer climates owing to its ability to withstand scorching summer months.
Apart from its ability to withstand heat and light, St. Augustine grass is also noted for its shade tolerance.
Is St Augustine Invasive?
Just like Bermuda grass, St. Augustine grass is invasive and spreads quickly. However, there are a few things you can do to stop St. Augustine grass from spreading such as keeping your lawn mowed at roughly 1.5–2 inches in height.
Bermuda grass and St. Augustine grass are two of the most preferred warm-season for several great reasons. Bermuda grass is more drought-tolerant than St. Augustine grass but doesn’t do well in shady areas of your lawn for which the latter is a great choice.
- Cals Arizona: Phoenix Lawn Watering Guide
Hi, Alex Kuritz here. Growing up I remember that my family had one of the best lawns in the neighborhood. Richly green and lush. I did a lot as I grew up in terms of caring and tending for not only my family’s lawn but also my neighbors. I can say I have years of experience, and I am here to share it with you.