Tall Fescue vs Kentucky Bluegrass: Differences + Which to Choose

Between Tall Fescue and Kentucky bluegrass (KBG), which one should you plant in your lawn?  While both are cool-season grasses, there are a number of factors unique to each of them that will help you choose which one is most suitable for your yard.

The difference between Kentucky Bluegrass vs tall fescue is the cost factor and appearance. Tall fescue requires about 1 lb of nitrogen fertilizer per 1000 sq. ft. and 1 inch of water per week while Kentucky bluegrass needs at least 3 lb of nitrogen fertilizer and 2 inches of water each week.

Below, I’ve delved deeper into the fine differences between these grass species.

Kentucky Bluegrass vs Tall Fescue (Differences)

Since Kentucky bluegrass and Tall fescue are both cool-season grasses, these two turfgrass species have various similarities. Still, that doesn’t mean that there are no differences between the two. If anything, there are lots of differences between these two lawn grasses.

Tall Fescue vs Kentucky Bluegrass - Differences and Cost

Here’s a table that summarizes the differences between Kentucky Bluegrass and tall fescue:

Tall FescueKentucky Bluegrass
Tall fescue requires 1 lb of nitrogen fertilizer per 1000 sq. ft.KBG requires 3 - 6 lbs. of nitrogen per 1,000 sq. ft.
Develops bunchy sods and is more traffic-resistant.Forms dense sods but does not tolerate traffic stress as well.
Tall fescure requires only about 1 inch of water every week or 1.5 inches per week when grown in sandy soils.KBG requires at least 2” of water per week - twice as much of water as Tall fescue.
Is heat-tolerant and resistant to summertime weed invasions and diseasesVulnerable to weeds and diseases during summer and in generally hot climates
Tall fescues can tolerate moderate shade and require 4 hours of direct sunshine to survive.KBG tolerates shade but requires at least 8 hours of direct sunshine to survive.

What Are The Best Seeds?

For Tall Fescue seeds, I personally like the Highlander II Fescue grass seed that you can get here.

For Kentucky Bluegrass seed, I’ve been using Barenbrug’s Turf Blue HGT with Yellow Jacket Coating. This has performed best in almost all climates. Check it out here.

Water requirements

Another differentiating factor between these two grass species is the amount of water they require to stay healthy.

Kentucky bluegrass requires about twice as much water compared to Tall fescue. If you grow Kentucky bluegrass in your lawn, it will need at least 2” of water per week. When conditions are hot during summer, your lawn may require even 2 ½” per week.

On the other hand, tall fescue requires only about 1 inch of water every week. If your lawn is grown in sandy soils, you may need to apply about ½ inch of water every third day.

Fertilizer requirements

You’ll need to apply 1 pound nitrogen fertilizer per 1000 square feet of tall fescue lawn while Kentucky bluegrass is more fertilizer-intensive, requiring an average of 3 to 6 lbs. of nitrogen per 1,000 sq. ft. of lawn, per year.

For both kinds of grass, however, it is important to do a soil test to determine the deficient nutrient before choosing the best fertilizer for your lawn.

It is best to start to fertilize a fescue lawn in March or early April. Do not apply fertilizer after May 1st.

Shade tolerance

Both KBG and tall fescue grasses can resist a certain amount of shade and still thrive. However, while tall fescues require 4 hours of direct sunshine per day minimum to survive, Kentucky bluegrass at least 8 hours of direct sunlight to grow and thrive well. The Glade and Bensun are the most shade-resistant cultivars of KBG. If you’re trying to establish a lawn in a shady yard, you’d do well to choose tall fescue as your turfgrass.

Traffic tolerance

Moving on- unlike other fescue sub-species  – Tall fescue is more traffic-tolerant compared to Kentucky bluegrass, making it suitable for use on grounds that undergo heavy use  – such as sports pitches.

Seed germination time

In terms of growth and seed germination, Kentucky bluegrass seeds take longer to germinate in comparison to Tall fescue seeds.

Sod formation

Additionally, Kentucky bluegrass forms dense sods that spread out by themselves to cover even bare patches. Tall fescue, on the other hand, develops bunchy sods that eventually require re-seeding to get rid of bare patches in the lawn.

Weeds and growth

The final notable difference is their preferred growing conditions. While Kentucky bluegrass is vulnerable to weeds and diseases during summer and in generally hot climates, tall fescue is rather heat-tolerant and is resistant to summertime disease and weed invasions such as crabgrass.

Tall Fescue Identification + Pictures

Tall fescue leaves are flat, smooth, and shiny on the underside, with pronounced ribs on the upper surface. The stems are 3-4 feet tall, supporting a nodding panicle that is 4-12 inches long.

Is Tall Fescue The Best Cool Season Grass Type?

Tall fescue  – known by the scientific name Festuca arundinacea  – is a popular turfgrass species that was introduced into America from Asia and Europe. It thrives in humid temperate regions, where it can grow up to about 16-inches.

It also does well in wet-soil regions and doesn’t require lots of sunshine exposure, hence s good turf grass choice for lawns that already contain other types of flora.

  • Despite being a cool-season grass, Tall fescue is known to be more heat, drought, and traffic tolerant than most typical cool-season turfgrass species.
  • When grown by itself without mixing in other grass species, Tall fescue grass develops to form rough, bunchy turfs with a lush green appearance.

There now exist hybrid varieties that possess a finer texture and form denser turfs. You can also identify Tall fescue by observing the venation, as the upper side of this grass species’ leaf blades contain longitudinal venation.

Tall fescue grass varieties also spot pointed leaf tips. Meanwhile, the dull appearance of the upper sides of the leaf blades contrasts with the glossy texture on the lower side.

Tall fescue is quite saline-tolerant and can do well in soils with pH levels of between 5.4- 6.2. It also features an extensive fibrous root system and can form sods through underground shoots (rhizomes).

Tall fescue grass also has smooth, circular flowering stems and is known to lack a definite ligule.

You can identify Tall fescue seeds by their oval shape and tan-brown color. The seeds also have slim, circular rachillas.

Kentucky Bluegrass Identification + Pictures

Kentucky Bluegrass leaves are 6 to 12 inches long and boat-shaped at the tips. They appear to be smooth, soft, and about 1/8 to 1/4 inch wide.

Kentucky Bluegrass

Kentucky bluegrass  – scientifically known as Poa pratensis  – typically grows to a height of between 18-24 inches, with a canoe-shaped leaf tip. During spring, it develops new leaves every ten days, with the duration increased to about 22 days during summer and fall.

During winter, however, leaf production depends on the region’s climate. In Northern regions, there’s no leaf production in winter, as opposed to transition zones where leaf production doesn’t stop all through the year.

From spring to summer, new leaf blades that appear on Kentucky bluegrass grow up to about 4 inches tall with this length gradually reducing as the year progresses into late summer and fall. This is because leaf blade length is determined by day-length, with the blades able to grow taller during the longer summer days than during the shorter fall days.

The leaf angle also differs by season, with new leaf blades appearing during spring and early summer being erect and those appearing from late summer and fall being decumbent.

Kentucky bluegrass typically develops rhizomes that sprout up from the leaf axils, just above the ground surface. The rhizomes grow downwards into the soil from where they develop and branch out.

During spring and early summer, however, the growing sections at the tip of the rhizomes grow upwards and branch out as above-ground shoots. Kentucky bluegrass rhizomes typically have a two-year lifespan.

Which Grass to Choose

Whether to choose Tall fescue or Kentucky bluegrass largely depends on where you live. In the transition zone (the coast of the Atlantic through Kansas), summer days tend to be too hot and arid for Kentucky bluegrass. Tall fescue, on the other hand, is a heat-tolerant grass species that will definitely thrive in the same region.

Finally, depending on what lawn aesthetic you’re going for, you can also always blend these two cool-season grass species for varied results.

References

Leave a Comment