Should you sod or hydroseed? If you’ve just recently bought a new residential or commercial property, you’re probably wondering whether to go with sodding or hydroseeding.
Sodding is the fastest yet expensive way of establishing a lawn while hydroseeding is slow yet cheaper. When compared to grass seeding, sodding is a much faster lawn establishment process of the two, but hydroseeding as a third option has unique advantages such as preventing soil erosion in the yard and producing a high-quality turf.
Below, I’ve done detailed descriptions guide on the differences between these lawn establishment methods- including cost differences and what you should consider when choosing between them.
Sod vs Hydroseed – Differences
While both are effective ways of establishing a lawn from scratch, there exist multiple differences between sod and hydroseed, the first being their physical form. Here’s a quick comparison between sodding and hydroseeding.
|Is a solid mass of soil and fully-grown grass||Is a liquid mixture containing seeds, mulch, water, and fertilizer|
|Machinery required: skid-steer||Machinery required: retrofitted truck|
|Instant fully-grown lawn, ready for use immediately after||You’ll have to wait for about five weeks for the lawn to be ready for use.|
|Minimal maintenance requirements||Requires detailed maintenance from as soon as the seeds are planted|
|Can be completely DIY||You must hire a contractor at the initial seed planting stage|
|Offers no room for cross-breeding experimentation with different turfgrass varieties||One can blend several different seed species for a unique lawn|
Sod is a solid mass of soil and fully-grown grass, while hydroseed is a liquid mixture containing seeds, mulch, water, and fertilizer. Sod is usually installed after the grass has already germinated, and it takes a few weeks to take root on the landscape it is installed. Hydroseeding, on the other hand, is generally installed on prepared lawn soil where the seed in the mixture will germinate. Below are some pictures on an area treated with a product called Grotrax, which is a form of hydroseed in a roll out mat that you can use for spot treating or even full yard plantings.
This is what is looks like on not well prepared area and that has dogs that have access to it. The area that you apply Grotrax to should be tilled, smooth, and have a mix-in of topsoil. The area below will come in spotty.
The other difference is that sodding requires a different set of tools to hydroseeding. When manually laying sod pallets on your lawn, you’ll need a sod roller (skid steer) to move the sod pallets as you work your way around the bare lawn.
Hydroseeding, on the other hand, requires various specific machinery including a retrofitted truck. Most homeowners may not have such machinery and may opt to hire if they have the expertise. If not, you’ll need to use the services of a professional hydroseeding company.
How long it takes
The third difference is the time it takes to have a fully-grown lawn with lush greenery. With sodding, you’ll have an instantly beautiful lawn that’s ready for use as soon as the installation is done. Hydroseeding- on the other hand- could take between four-five weeks for the seeds to germinate.
Lawn establishment via hydroseeding is more labor-intensive compared to sodding. With sodding, all you have to do is lay the sod, followed by the scheduled watering and mowing of the fully-grown grass.
Lawn establishment via hydroseeding, on the other hand, requires detailed care from the moment you plant the seeds. Before the grass even matures and is ready for the initial mowing, you shall have already put in lots of effort on providing the right conditions for seed germination and plant growth.
DIY vs professional installation
The fifth difference is that sodding can be entirely DIY, while hydroseeding has to be done by a contractor who has the necessary machinery for the same- that is- a retrofitted truck.
Timing and mixing seed varieties
Next, sod lawns can be established at any time of the year, though the preferable window is late spring to late summer while hydroseeding should be done anytime between March and October.
The final difference is that sodding doesn’t accord homeowners as much experimental room as hydroseeding. This is because sod pallets can only be of a specific turfgrass species.
The most common commercially sold sod species include Bermuda sod, Fescue sod, and Kentucky bluegrass sod. Hydroseed species- on the other hand- can be mixed for a unique and visually intriguing blend of grass color.
Cost: Sod vs hydroseed vs seeding
Lawn establishment via sod pallets is the most expensive option of the three, as hydroseeding costs about 70% less. An acre of sod pallets, for instance, may cost up to $10,000 while hydroseeding can cost anywhere between $2500-dollars – $5,000; with the extra costs going towards hiring a licensed hydroseed contractor.
The lower cost of hydroseed takes into account that the buyer/homeowner has to do the early plant life maintenance themselves whereas sod pallets are sold fully grown.
Traditional seeding is the cheapest option, as most turf grass seeds can be bought commercially for less than $1000 lawns established using this method normally take the longest to be fully established (8-10 weeks).
Choosing Which Method to Use
The appropriate lawn establishment method for you will depend on aspects of your personal preferences.
If you’re looking for fast results, then sodding is the way to go. However, if you’re on a tight budget, it’s advisable to go for the cheaper hydroseeding.
Moving on, if you’re a busy individual with little time to take care of your lawn, sodding is logically the better option. On the other hand, if you’re a gardening and landscaping enthusiast that enjoys the sense of satisfaction that comes with establishing your own beautiful lawn from scratch, then hydroseeding will give you the chance to experience that kind of journey to success.
Just to recap, while sodding and hydroseeding may each have their pros and cons they’re both effective methods of lawn establishment. Your choice between the two should depend on a variety of factors including your budget limit and willingness to undertake the necessary lawn care.
Check out more lawn care tips and best lawn products.
Hi, Alex K. here. Growing up I remember that my family had one of the best lawns in the neighborhood. Richly green and lush. I did a lot as I grew up in terms of caring and tending for not only my families lawn but also my neighbors. I can say I have years of experience, and I am here to share it with you.
Please leave your comments below as I try to respond to everyone that has questions.